Home General Training Discussions

Do I need a road bike?

Hi EN peeps:

I need some help in deciding if I should buy a road bike. I only have tri bikes (one for the trainer and one I use for racing).  The only reason I resisted in buying a road bike for so long is I wanted to focus on riding a tri bike (being new to riding).  That being said, the reasons for buying a road bike now are:  1) I moved to NYC and a tri bike is not the best for navigating in these parts, not to mention the pot holes and bad roads; 2) Several people have told me that riding a road bike will make me a better and stronger cyclist, and 3) I want to be a better cyclist.

My only hesitation is that I'm concerned that riding a road bike will make me not as comfortable on my tri bike and may impact my race day performance.  That being said, I am doing my 5th IM this year and except for my first tri season, I have only ridden exclusively on tri bikes.  I am not experienced enough to know if a road bike will improve my bike performance and handling.

Any thoughts or comments are appreciated.

Thank you.

Joanna

IM MOO 2010

Comments

  • What a road bike will allow you to do is ride with a group which will help you become a better cyclist. I find riding with a group of roadies pretty fun and makes you work hard. You will find most people here ride road bikes during the beginning of the season and then switch to there tri bikes. You would want to be mostly on your tri bike during your race prep.

     

  • Wow, Joanna, I thought I was the only other odd duck who only owned a Tri Bike before finally buying a road bike! If your only hesitation is about the comfort/fit of being used to the tri-bike, let that go and get the road bike! To be honest, it took me a long time to be comfy on a road bike because I was so used to the TT position. Still today (after several years with Hobbs, my road bike) I prefer being tucked in TT position on the bike. I ride Hobbs exclusively all winter and it takes very little time for me each spring/summer to get re-adjusted to my TT bike. That said- yes- I notice the same power drop switching from Road to TT bike that everyone else does- but that usually adjusts as well and frankly I just don't sweat it 'cause I know I'm faster on Fiona.

    Finally- one of the best things I did was buy a road bike. It gives me more opportunities to ride with the roadies and that alone really makes me stronger. If you can afford it, I recommend getting one.
  • Joanna- Something that Rich said that has stuck in my mind.. Road bike = fun. Tri bike = work. I ride my road bike in the off season. Road bike makes climbing so much easier and as others have said, riding with groups is a great way to meet new folks and get strong. I do spend time riding in the drops and when it's time to do to "work" I'll transition into the aero bars a bit at a time. Building your core in the off season (ck out Leighs killer core work!) will also help keep your midsection strong for riding aero.

    My motto- a gal can NEVER have too many shoes or bikes!!
  • I own 2 tri bikes and one road bike (Trek Madone 6.9).   I plan on following the EN guidance and shifting to the tri bikes when I come out of the OS.   But for now, it's mostly the road bike.  I drove up to GA this weekend to ride the Azalea Century (yes, I know it's a leeeetle longer than the scheduled OS ride).  I don't do many group rides other than organized centuries and it's definitely safer with a road bike.  I trust ME on a tri-bike in a group but not others, and I'm sure most feel the same way.  Fortunately, this weekend only one guy going the whole way showed up on a tri bike and the peloton dropped him about halfway.  The road bike is just more responsive for this type of riding.  And trust me, it was work!  We had about 25 in the peloton at about 30 miles, and 9 at the end.  The rest got spit out the back ... not always fun when you are pulling and sometimes even drafting depending on the strength of the person pulling. 

  • Thanks everybody for these really helpful comments. You've pretty much affirmed my decision to get a road bike.

    Joanna
  • Make sure you post pictures when you do get it.

     

    Good Luck

  • Having two bikes (road and tri) gives you much more training flexibility. While a road bike isn't necessary to ride with roadies, it does allow you blend in and be inviso. If you show up to a roadie ride on a tri bike you are instantly marked as a poor bike handler and general Fred until you prove otherwise.

    A good friend of mine owns a bike rental biz. He says there are tons of good deals on used bikes to be had out there. I'd check that out first.

  • I have both a road bike (Natasha) and tri Bike (Kristyn). Just like having two vehicles, you can have one for one specific purpose and the other one for a back-up, one for trainer other one for outside, one for traveling (I take this bike with me when I go on a far vacation, because you don't know the terrain enuf) and the other stays behind, and more importantly a bike to use when the other is in the shop.

    I love that I have two different ones.

  • I love the names of your bikes!   I didn't even think of giving them female names.  I've given my first two road bikes to my sons.  First road bike was PIG...due to weight (KHS Flite 500 alloy bike).  Second was FALCON (Cannondale Synapse).  Current roadie is BLAZE (Trek Madone).  My tri bikes are BLACK BEAUTY and DRAGON FIRE.   I think Natasha is a badass name.

  • The bottom line is there's always a good reason to get a new bike. 'Nuff said.
  • Posted By Bill Russell on 08 Mar 2010 09:26 PM

    The bottom line is there's always a good reason to get a new bike. 'Nuff said.



    My sentiments exactly!

     

    So, Joanne, what road bike are you going to get?!

  • I'll just say that I have 6 bikes at the moment and a 7th on the way. 6 of them are for different purposes (only one duplicate type) ... you can guess what my vote would be :-)

    It took me almost 40 weeks just to name my daughter so needless to say I have not come up with names for any of the bikes other... red, black, race bike, fixie, etc.
  • @ Matt - until I settled on "Blaze", my Trek Madone was affectionately referred to as "What the Hell".
Sign In or Register to comment.