Home General Training Discussions

Adamo vs Cobb saddle?

I could really use some saddle advice from the group. I currently gave an Adamo racing saddle and have had it for 3 years. This past season I trained and raced my first full IM, which meant longer rides and a lot more time in the saddle. In turn, I ended up with an area on my both sides of my bum that seemed to constantly take the brunt of things. I was hesitant to switch saddles and fit as I got closer to my races and just got through it (with the aid of several tubes of anti-chafe cream). image

I am fairly certain that the saddle is too wide for me by the marks it leaves on my backside and think it's best for me to look for a new one. I like the split nose design and now, several manufacturers have their own spin on this, but I need one that is more narrow. Maybe for now, I should try some zip ties to see if this at least fixes the problem, but that seems more like it would bring the nose closer together instead of the mid section where the problem seems to be.

Any thoughts out there on Adamo vs Cobb (or other suggestions) for what I'm looking for? Thanks!

Comments

  • I had a similar experience with Adamo. I tried the Cobb v-max, but it was too soft and I ultimately had similar inner thigh discomfort on long rides. I have settled in this past season with the specialized sitero. Narrow, moderately stiff, and with the cutout design. So far so good.
  • @Brad, I personally love my Adamo so I'm bias; what I would suggest though is to evaluate making that choice together with a new bike fit. Talk to Todd at TTbike fit and he can certainly give the best possible advice (online). Second to none!!!! And he's an EN partner.
    http://www.ttbikefit.com
  • I have two different Cobb saddles. I like them both. The good news is they have a 30 day return policy. My point is if your fit is correct then you have to try them.
  • I have the Cobb v-max on my tri bike and the v-plus on my road bike. Both are great saddles. The one thing I've noticed is you can't wear a thick pass with them, especially the v-max. For example, the DeSoto 400 was agony on the v-max after a couple hours.

    Cobb is very helpful about recommending saddles if you call or email. I've heard John Cobb answers the phone a lot of times. If the Adamo is too wide, the v-plus might be a better fit for you than the v-max. Cobb also has a couple of new saddles out, but I don't have any experience with them.

    You can always try it and send it back if you don't like it.
  • @Brad I am an Adamo guy. Have the Breakaway on my tribike and Podium on the roadie. Have tried the Cobb V-Flow but liked the Breakaway better. This spring I tried the Cobb Gen2 and hated it for the opposite reason you can't ride Adamo.

    The Gen2 is much narrower than the Adamo, and with the easy return policy is worth the try.
  • For me it has been:

    Specialized Sitero>Cobb V-Flow Max>ISM Adamo Race>ISM Adamo Road>Cobb V-Flow Plus>Every other saddle

    I was literally one of the first consumers to get a Sitero saddle when they first came out in early 2013 and I really, really like it.

  • Posted By Steve West on 09 Nov 2014 09:47 AM


    @Brad I am an Adamo guy. Have the Breakaway on my tribike and Podium on the roadie. Have tried the Cobb V-Flow but liked the Breakaway better. This spring I tried the Cobb Gen2 and hated it for the opposite reason you can't ride Adamo.



    The Gen2 is much narrower than the Adamo, and with the easy return policy is worth the try.

    Uh, depends on the model. The ISM Adamo Attack is 110 mm wide, the Gen2 is 130; most other saddles mentioned in this thread are 135 wide. For those for whom narrower is better (I'm one), the Adamo Attack is it. In addition, the central depression is wider, longer, and deeper than other brands. People come in all sizes, so do saddles, it's critical to have a good match.

  • Brad, I have the adamo. However, I will tell you that both Adamo and Cobb advise that most issues are caused by improper fit. Cobb says that it is usually because the seat is too high. I know I had to move around my adamo up, down forward, back and tilt before I got it right.  Good luck


  • Posted By Al Truscott on 09 Nov 2014 11:07 AM

    Posted By Steve West on 09 Nov 2014 09:47 AM


    @Brad I am an Adamo guy. Have the Breakaway on my tribike and Podium on the roadie. Have tried the Cobb V-Flow but liked the Breakaway better. This spring I tried the Cobb Gen2 and hated it for the opposite reason you can't ride Adamo.



    The Gen2 is much narrower than the Adamo, and with the easy return policy is worth the try.

    Uh, depends on the model. The ISM Adamo Attack is 110 mm wide, the Gen2 is 130; most other saddles mentioned in this thread are 135 wide. For those for whom narrower is better (I'm one), the Adamo Attack is it. In addition, the central depression is wider, longer, and deeper than other brands. People come in all sizes, so do saddles, it's critical to have a good match.

    True when comparing max width.  Maybe I should have said the nose feels long and narrow like a traditional roadie seat because there is no taper in the front half which is very different than the Breakaway or Podium.  

  • Brad - is it the nose of the saddle that is too wide, or the back part. I know several people who solved the problem of the nose being too wide by putting a zip tie on the rails below the nose and pulling it closer together. Maybe that would work for you if the problem is the nose. I really like my adamo time trial.
  • I had the same problem this past season with the Adamo. It was OK until I started the longer rides. I went with the Cobb 2+ & it solved my problems. Edwin is correct, fit is very Important.
    I also started wearing bibs, with a thin pad, for all of my longer rides.
  • Thanks guys. So great to hear the varied responses and I know people are passionate about what saddles work for them - it is clearly a personal thing according to fit. My bike fit seems pretty decent but that's a whole different conversation since you don't really know until you find the perfect fitter and maybe I haven't. I have 2 issues that have plagued me: one being the saddle issue and another being my bars...both seem to be manufacturer, rather than fit but I need to address both before next season. I will try Cobb since they have a good return policy and I know they are "self fitting" since I installed one to my wife's satisfaction 2 years ago. I am in a situation where I'm more comfortable with a bib on the trainer and tri shorts on the road so go figure. Bottom line is that's I feel that I know what feels good at this point and hopefully 1 month should be enough time to figure out what works. I will keep you all in the loop as to what I try and success or failures. Thanks!
  • Saddles are completely personal so individual recommendations are not worth the online print; and any sweeping recommendation of Adamo over Cobb or vice versa would be an overstatement. Over the years, I've tried a number of Adamo saddles at expos and hated everyone I ever tried. Then in 2013 the Slowtwitch saddle tour came to Tampa and I took advantage of trying multiple saddles, including many by Cobb on a Retul Muve set to my fit coordinates. I went back and forth and ended up deciding - to my great surprise - that the Adama Attack was the best for me. I love, love, love, that saddle which means, per Al's comment, that I need the narrow base.



    My one observation is that I could tell within a minute of riding on the Muve whether the saddle was a good fit or not. So I completely reject the advice of those who claim a saddle has to be broken in before its comfortable. A lot of people told me in the past that they needed time to get used to an Adamo. Or they have zip tied the front together to make it more narrow. To me, that just means it did not fit. So in my opinion, it wasn't until Adamo made the Attack that they were a brand even worth considering. Bottomline, focus on the saddle, not the brand.
Sign In or Register to comment.