Home General Training Discussions

Ironman Texas - Swim Skin vs. Shirtless

 I do not own a swim skin...and I am not all that excited about spending $250 on one between now and next Saturday for IM Texas.  As an alternative, I has a tri suit made through my local club team that has no pockets and is very light weight and tight.  Problem is, it was a custom order and was done incorrectly (that pad in the shorts is annoying to run in).  So, here are my options:

 

1. Fork over $250 for a swim skin.  My research tells me there IS an advantage wearing one of these, especially across an IM.  Everything I can find says we are talking about 1:15-1:30.  If you add my tri top to this (which has a rear pocket that I fear would act as a sail in the water), I am thinking it isn't unreasonable to expect close to a 2:00-2:15 difference across the less than 1:08/1:10 in which I hope to swim 2.4 miles.  That leads me to me second thought...

 

2.  Go shirtless.  That 1:15-1:30 advantage is over a swimmer wearing speedos.  So, I can live with that...am I don't see why my Desoto tri shorts would be any slower than a speedo, right?  The only thing I worry about here is how big of a pain in the @$$ it might be to put the tri top on in T1.

I can live with 1:15 with a 'clear conscious'...potentially hitting the 2:00 mark seems like a steep enough penalty for me to call one of these audibles.

 

(3.  A third option would be wearing that tri suit I had made as a swim skin - it has no pockets and is tight.  Then I would take it off in transition.  It MAY be quicker to do that than to try to put on the tri top in T1.)

Comments

  • Stephen: You need to check the rules. I'm not sure if a shirt is required on the swim. I believe ti is on the run. It also depends on if you are trying for Kona and need the extra speed. Honestly, I'd go with #3.
  • Stephen, I have a Desoto 78 degree top you could borrow. You could put it over your EN tri top and take it off in T1. The 78 degree top is like a "swimskin" top.
  • Bob - that would be awesome! I would really appreciate it! I will PM you my info and we'll coordinate a 'fitting' for this week. I will be in town Tuesday night.

    To Penny's point...anyone know if a shirt is required during the swim?
  • FWIW, last yr at IMLou, more than half of the men were swimming with no top, so I have to imagine it is legal.
  • It may only be the bike/run where shirts are required.
  • It can be really hard to pull a shirt over your head after the swim. In one of my very first sprint triathlons I think it took me 2 minutes to get it on. Of course I also looked ridiculous in T1 trying my best to get going!
  • Posted By Tom Glynn on 13 May 2012 05:57 PM

    It can be really hard to pull a shirt over your head after the swim. In one of my very first sprint triathlons I think it took me 2 minutes to get it on. Of course I also looked ridiculous in T1 trying my best to get going!



    John is volunteering in the T1 men's change tent. I'm sure he'd be happy to help!

  • There are some full zip tri tops as well that are much easier to put on a wet body...but they aren't EN style though....
Sign In or Register to comment.