Options
HOW "SLOW" IS AERO WORTH IT?
I'm using the 10 mph rule to stay AERO. That is, if climbing slower than 10 i sit up and use the time to REST my neck, butt, etc.
Any thoughts???
Any thoughts???
0
Comments
The answer is their is power savings at ALL speeds. The 13mph number is that above that 90% of power is to overcome frontal resistance. Below this it is less than 90%, but STILL the major factor. Some good papers on where power goes to (air resistance, chain friction, tire resistance, bearings, etc) by James Martin from University of Utah ESS lab. Most recent I saw a webinar from here that showed study data from power data in tops, hoods, drops uphill time trial at <10mph. Convinced me to stay aero at all costs when racing, also train SOME hills this way.</p>
The really important thing is that the sit-up factor is for slowness due to uphill grade, not for wind in your face. I'll sit up for a break going uphill somewhere in the <12 mph range, in part to give the legs a break and in part because it's a little easier to generate the slightly higher power sitting up... <br />
If the wind is at your back going uphill, then you can afford to sit up at a little higher speed. But if the wind is in your face at all, stay down unless you are just forced to sit up by too steep a grade. It should go without saying that you HAVE to stay down if you are on a flat (or very low grade) and are going slowly because of wind in your face instead of gravity.
Yes, William you are correct. The science can only say what the numbers are, not what is "best" for each person. While you may use more watts in sitting up, it may save your back for later in the run, or allow more O2 intake. Everyone needs to evaluate this for them selves. Just like the lowest position you can get into is not the best for every distance and age. ย
As Richard notes, going upright provides a good opportunity to stretch the low back - especially nice for us 50+ boomers.
I also find it easier to vary the pelvic angle and engage my glutes over my quads, and vice versa, when in the upright position. I find this a little more challenging in aero, but getting good practice on the trainer during NOS and now GF plans.